A Dad’s Guide to Disney Princesses, from Ariel to Cinderella

If you have daughters, you might be able to steer clear of the American Girl dolls, but you cannot avoid the Disney princesses. They’re in movies and on lunchboxes. There are raincoats and boots and vitamins with them. There are dolls and sticker sets and games where you build plastic cupcakes tailor-made for each character. The princesses are inescapable.

Some are wonderful characters and excellent role models for the important young ladies in your life. Others are . . . less so. Herewith is a ranking of the Disney princesses by moral character and general awesomeness:

#9 Ariel: The Little Mermaid may have been the movie that reinvigorated Disney animation, but as an example for little girls, it’s the worst.

The real story of the movie is that a man’s daughter falls in love with some guy she’s never even spoken with, goes through body modification in the hopes that he’ll love her back—and then her moronic crush costs her father his kingdom.

Imagine your daughter coming home and saying, “Dad, this biker gang drove through town today and the guy leading it was amazing and I love him. I’m going to get a bunch of piercings and tattoos so that I can join the gang. And then I just know he’ll love me back!!” Well, that’s what Ariel does. And her father winds up paying for the tats.

And the “happy” ending in all of this is that to marry her biker-gang prince, Ariel has to live in a whole new world and be separated from her father for the rest of his life. Which she does without any hesitation. At all.

Keep your daughters far, far away from this movie.

#8 Pocahontas: The lessons of Pocahontas might be worse. A band of conquistadors suddenly appears and will soon commit genocide against the Native American people. But one of these guys is dreamy! So Pocahontas lectures her dad about stereotyping and Anglophobia.

The only reason Pocahontas is ranked above Ariel is that she actually talks to John Smith before falling in love with the dope and betraying her people.

#7 Tiana/Rapunzel: You might not realize it, but the characters from Tangled and The Princess and the Frog have a lot in common: They’re plucky. They believe in the power of their dreams. And they teach girls a terrible lesson: No matter how bad a boy might seem on the surface, a girl can change him through the power of love.

Here’s a Life Spoiler for little princesses who think they can change bad boys: No, you can’t.

#6 Aurora/Snow White: Two more princesses with a lot in common. They’re both blank slates who spend the interesting parts of their movies asleep. And they both teach girls that good-hearted people trust strangers.

#5 Jasmine: The moral lesson at the heart of Aladdin is pretty much: Your father doesn’t know best and you should rebel against him. Hard.

But in fairness to Princess Jasmine, her father is a weak, easily-led fool. So while Princess Jasmine isn’t a good role model for your daughter—because you’re not a dimwitted sultan—she’s just fine for girls with rotten or absent fathers.

#4 Belle: Now we get to the good princesses. Beauty and the Beast is the most Broadway of the Disney movies and, as such, is kind of annoying. But the moral of the story is fantastic: Don’t automatically trust the good-looking, popular jock because he’s probably a bro-creep—even if everyone else likes him.

That’s the textual message. The subtext is even better: Belle teaches girls that reading is the gateway to a life of adventure. As the kids say, +1.

Also: Belle is willing to go to prison in exchange for her father’s freedom. Which makes it totally worth sitting through the cloying show tunes.

#3 Mulan: Where Belle offers to be thrown in a dungeon to secure her father’s safety, Mulan goes to war for her dad. The message of Mulan for girls is simple, unmistakable, and awesome: Honor and family before all.

#2 Anna and Elsa: The Frozen princesses get grouped together even though they offer different lessons.

Elsa is a model of self-sacrifice and filial love. Also, repression: She holds back her mutant powers for years after her father’s death in deference to his memory. Also, she understands that it would be insane for her sister to marry a guy she just met.

And Anna, for her part, ditches not one, but two dreamboats in order to save her sister. She’s even ready to get sliced in half by a broadsword for Elsa. Because she knows that love for her family trumps boy-crushes. All hail Anna, the anti-Ariel.

#1 Cinderella: Disney’s greatest princess is also its most underappreciated. The conventional wisdom on Cinderella is that she’s a Mary Sue who does nothing except wait for a prince to rescue her. But that’s dead wrong. Cinderella is the embodiment of two of great virtues: courage and kindness. She suffers terribly, the victim of both circumstance and genuine evil. And yet she is neither embittered nor defeated.

Disney’s 2015 live-action Cinderella makes the lesson explicit. As Cinderella’s mother lay dying, she tells her daughter, “I have to tell you a secret that will see you through all the trials that life can offer: Have courage and be kind.” Those are words to live by.

Cinderella is an object lesson in humanity and grace—not just for little girls, but for everyone.

  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  

newsletter-signup
  • LeftistsStink

    Great piece. Just discovered your site, my new favorite!

  • Philip Scott

    Gonna have to disagree with #2. Overarching story line is repression and isolation for both sisters. One is locked away for most of her life the other is separated from her sister for no apparent reason (her perspective). While Elsa’s suppression of her “mutant powers” certainly could be a good thing the extremes they are taken to are anything but (Conceal Don’t Feel song). Even the freedom brought about by Elsa embracing herself is taken too far, no regard for the consequences (Let it Go song) and whole second half of the movie. For me this one is right up there with Little Mermaid.

  • valjean

    Ha! Great list! By the end I realized we’re even in sync: our twin 8-year-old (and still princess-adoring) daughters have seen (and generally loved) your #1-6 … but not #7-9.

    We have our own reasons for piling on: My spouse also hates “Mermaid” for Ursula’s creepy sexuality, “Poco” is anti-historical nonsense (the English were gold crazy? her tribe is peace-loving?), and “Frog/Rapunzel” really aren’t stories for young children (of either gender).

  • Mack

    I gave my daughter Robin Hood stories as an antidote.

  • Robert Smith

    What about Merida of Brave?

    She certainly is brave and skilled, but she is willing to feed her mother a cursed (poisoned?) cake just so she can have a little more say in who she marries. And it works! Though it almost gets her mother killed in the process.

  • Pingback: Jonathan V. Last on the Trump Phenomenon, Captain America, and Barbie Life in the Dreamhouse()

  • MC88

    As an adult I realized Belle is a snob. She looks down on the simple towns people who work all day and make her life possible while she wanders through town wondering why they are so simple (hint: they are too busy to spend all day reading fairy tales). Though they are apparently well read enough to keep the book shop in business.

  • Pingback: A Definitive Ranking of the Worst (and Best) Barbie Movies Ever Made, by a Father Who’s Seen Them All - Acculturated()

  • Angus Castle

    Nicely drawn together list! Though I will say I don’t agree with your view on Elsa – she was an awful sister to Elsa, including practically sending her into death and setting off a huge snowman. Not a good role model imo