Fri. August 17
Russia’s Rock N Roll Riot
By now it’s an established fact that the punk revolution of the late 1970s led to a genuine artistic achievement, as the movement and its Do It Yourself (DIY) ethic gave bands like U2, Green Day, and Radiohead the ability to create their own sounds in unique and imaginative ways. Incredibly, punk is still producing exciting art; one of the best bands I’ve heard recently is Neon P*ss. I know, I know–the vulgar names do get tiresome, but a lot of the music is still very cool. It remains one of the joys of life to come across a talented young band and watch them flourish.
Although it puts on an angry and nihilistic face, punk, or the best punk, is about trying to live a virtuous life in a world that often seems compromised by commercialism, war, and a basic lack of integrity. This is the 30th anniversary year of the punk magazine Maximum Rocknroll, and leafing through the anniversary issue it’s clear that punks today value what punks back in the 1970s and 80s valued: honesty, community, art for art’s sake, and real friendship.
That said, MRR has certainly fallen short in its lack of support for the band P**** Riot, a Russian all-female punk rock collective. Three members of the group were sentenced to two-year prison terms today by a Moscow court for “hooliganism motivated by religious hatred”. This for performing a song at the Cathedral of Christ the Savior which asked Mary, the Mother of God–or “Theotokos”–to “drive Putin away.”
Maximum Rocknroll has not covered theP**** Riot scandal enough, and that’s a shame, because one thing punk is supposed to prize above all else is truth-telling. Furthermore, there’s also a proud history of punk subversion of communist tyranny. After all, Václav Havel and the leaders of the 1960s revolt against communism in Czechoslovakian were deeply influenced by American rock and roll–particularly the band the Velvet Underground, which was a founding influence on punk. A group of young Czech hippies formed the group the Plastic People of the Universe (named after a Frank Zappa lyric) and were soon banned by the government. A fan of the Rolling Stones, Havel saw and heard in rock and roll “a temperament, a nonconformist state of the spirit, an anti-establishment orientation, an aversion to philistines, and an interest in the wretched and humiliated.”
Partly as a result of their love of the Velvet Underground, Havel and his friends launched “Charter 77,” which called for free artistic expression. The document spread widely through the underground, ultimately making its way to Poland and the Solidarity movement. It is no exaggeration then to say that American rock and roll helped bring down Communism.
Whether that same spirit of freedom can still withstand the challenges posed by the Putin regime remains to be seen.





Pingback: Instapundit » Blog Archive » MARK JUDGE: Russia’s Rock N Roll Riot….
From the translation posted at the YouTube video of their performance:
“All parishioners are crawling and bowing
The ghost of freedom is in heaven
Gay pride sent to Siberia in chains”
“The head of the KGB is their chief saint”
“Holy shit, shit, Lord’s shit!”
“Belt of the Virgin is no substitute for mass-meetings
In protest of our Ever-Virgin Mary!”
They interrupted worship at the Cathedral the Communists once destroyed, in order to mock the worshippers and slander the faith the Communists suppressed. That is wildly offensive to the people who suffered so much under Communism, and hooliganism by any definition. This is no different than scrawling swastikas on the walls of a synagogue during a Sabbath service.
Maybe Russian justice is too severe; a beat-down by the parishioners would probably be more appropriate than prison. But I have no sympathy for them.
One question: Was P***y Riot performing in the Cathedral with the permission of the Diocese? It’s hard to discern from the video if the people in the Church actually disturbed worshippers or extras paid to look disturbed. Are the men attempting to stop the PR members State Police, or the Cathedral’s own security?Freedom of expression doesn’t cover trespassing and disrupting someone else’s sacred space. That is a tactic of fascists.
I read this amusing and provocative article ages ago about the connection between Eastern Orthodox Christianity and its connection to punk music.
http://orlenkotalk.blogspot.jp/2005/10/death-to-world-punks-turned-monks.html
If any Glenn Reynolds readers bothered to read this post, they should know those kids in the D.C. PR protest were probably interns told to show up by their bosses. Not very punk like at all.
Russia rejects the Sixties.
Perhaps they are right to, given the history of the West since then.
Pingback: Breakfast Links | Points and Figures
What is so funny, and perhaps telling, is that one of the best and most popular post-Soviet movies celebrates the rebellious and transformative power of the Rock n’ Roll. The movie, made in the 2008, is the brilliant musical called Stilyagi. You can see it on the youtube…
It is one of the Manolo’s most favorite recent movies.
Pingback: Russian Grrrls Need Better Friends « sitting on the edge of the sandbox, biting my tongue